|
Toward
Successful Blending Jan Scharman
Seven and a half years ago when Brent and I, each with children from a former
marriage, decided to marry, we were optimistic and full of hope. I had always
wanted to have a lot of children, and the thought of adding seven stepdaughters
to my small family of two daughters and one son was very exciting. Brent is a
licensed psychologist who had done marriage and family counseling for about
thirteen years, and I was a school counselor, working at the same time on a
doctorate in counseling psychology. Children and family were and are a priority
for both of us, and we believed that we had the training and interest to make a
second marriage work well. Prior to our dating, our children had known each
other from the neighborhood and school and were on friendly terms. We each came
from strong families and had a supportive network of friends. Everyone acted
appropriately enthusiastic at the announcement of our engagement, the gatherings
before our marriage were amicable, and the plans for an open house and honeymoon
fell easily into place. Brent arranged to have the temple president meet with
our children while our marriage ceremony was taking place, and this seemed to
help them feel a part of this most important event.
The only problem I identified before
our marriage was related to the delay in my receiving a cancellation of sealing
from my former spouse; this resulted in our marrying in the [Jordan River Temple
for time only. A few months later we were sealed in the Salt Lake Temple.
Brent did most of the accommodating
in this new family by moving into my home, adjusting to my family's schedules
and routines, and generally allowing the children's lives to continue with
little disruption. This stability was a wonderful gift for them and for me, but
it made Brent's adjustment more challenging-a fact that did not occur to me, I
am embarrassed to say, until we had been married for some time.
The first night after our honeymoon
when Brent arrived at my home after work, he knocked before entering. Even as he
did that, he knew it was unnecessary. However, he was no doubt uncomfortable
intruding on our space unannounced, and it clearly didn't feel like his space
yet. Initially, we did little as a family to help change that. I continued
preparing meals my children liked, did laundry and cleaning as I had done before
our marriage, kept the responsibility for helping the children with homework and
projects, and "generously" gave Brent some space of his own where he could put
his things. It was when Brent began to add his own touches to our home
(household purchases, small remodeling projects) and family (initiating
one-on-one contacts with my children) that he began to feel a part of the new
family unit. I certainly could have been more sensitive to the difficulty of
this major transition, and now wish I had facilitated the process by inviting
his help, sharing more of the household tasks with him, and even taking more
time to talk about what this was like for him.
Brent's children lived only about a
mile away, and we both had visions of frequent get-togethers which would result
in closeness, fond memories, and growing together as a family. In reality, the
visits initially did not occur as often as we would have liked, and individual
identities, complete with quite diverse likes and goals, quickly emerged. I soon
discovered that Brent's children had a strong desire to be close to him with
little need to relate to me-especially as a mother figure. During those first
few years, I cannot recall any particularly negative experiences with his
children, who have always been bright, well behaved, socially adept, and very
appropriate. But it was a shock for me to finally realize that they did not need
me to be their mother, and I was uncertain as to what other part I could or
should play. At first, I coped by detaching emotionally, and sometimes
physically. If I didn't reach out to them, I couldn't be rejected.
That whole process led to an unusual
and emotionally intense time for me, and the rush of new experiences, evolving
in unpredictable ways, left me feeling overwhelmed and somewhat off balance. I
had never, before this time, had any real exposure to the nature of second
marriages. None of my family members or close friends had been divorced or
widowed, and thus I found no other blended families after which to model or even
with which to compare my own experience. What I had learned growing up in a
strong and stable LDS family usually helped me with my own children but
sometimes seemed not to apply to the new family relationships in my life. I
wanted very much to be the ideal wife and mother but was confused by the
distance between me and my new family members-a distance that seemed at times
impossible to span.
While I was living out the process of
adjusting to remarriage, I was at the same time noticing how many of the
individuals I counseled were also feeling the impact of stepfamily living in one
way or another. Motivated by both personal and professional interest, I began
reading and learning about this family configuration. At first glance, the
blended family looked much like a first-marriage family; but I soon learned that
the blended family was different in significant ways. What follows in this
chapter is based on my study of stepfamily literature, interviews with
stepfamilies, and my own personal experience as it continues to evolve and
which, happily, is becoming more satisfying and rewarding each day.
A discussion about the remarried or
blended family can be challenging because any word describing the family tends
to be emotionally charged for someone who is living the experience. Some dislike
the step- words such as stepmother, stepchild, and so forth, because of the
negative connotation fostered in fairy tales and colloquial expressions over
time. Some avoid the term blended because of the implication that everyone is
mixed up together to create a new family unit, with individual identities
somehow blurring or even becoming lost all together. Others have tried to
describe this family type by using words such as reconstituted or bi-nuclear,
but these words seem unsatisfactory as well. The challenge of finding just the
right vocabulary only begins to suggest some of the complexity inherent in this
family type.
The literature can be a bit gloomy on
the subject of families and divorce, with an abundance of statistics suggesting
unhealthy family relationships and increased problems in school performance and
social skills. It is a clear fact that children in homes that are dysfunctional
tend not to do as well as children in well-functioning homes; likewise, homes
where there are major problems are more likely to experience a divorce. But not
all divorces occur in families that are hopelessly unable to learn, grow, and
progress. While divorce is always painful and disruptive, it is my opinion that
it is not the divorce and the subsequent remarriage that dooms children and
parents to a life of pain and difficulty, but rather the coping and parenting
skills of the adults who are modeling and setting the standard. Many of us
experience some sort of tragedy in our lives-financial concerns, difficult
moves, natural disasters, death of loved ones etc. The human soul tends to be
resilient and adaptive, and strength can emerge from adversity, whatever form
that may take. We are able to experience many crises that ultimately lead to
growth, learning, peace, and productivity.
John and Emily Visher, authors and
researchers of step families, agree and have outlined important characteristics
of stepfamilies which they believe are associated with satisfactory adjustment.
Building on their work and using my own experience and research, the following
is a discussion of conditions that increase the likelihood of stepfamily
success.
FAMILIES ARE INF0RMED
A woman came to me for counseling with the complaint that she thought she was
going crazy. She always viewed herself as a caring, reasonable, and mother. Her
previously happy three- and six-year-old had begun frequently fighting, having
temper tantrums and being very demanding of her time during the past months. She
felt jealous of her five-year-old daughters relationship with her husband, and
she was becoming more disappointed in his parenting skills. This was
uncharacteristic of how she viewed herself, and she was frightened because she
didn't understand what was happening. It was only after some discussion that she
quite by chance mentioned that she was in a second marriage of six months that
the five-year-old was her stepdaughter. She had seen no connection between what
she was personally experiencing and the family unit that had been established
only recently. When she was able to reframe her experience, looking at it not as
a personal failure but rather as an opportunity to learn how to manage the
complexities of stepfamily living, she was able to deal appropriately with the
challenges and move ahead with her relationships in an effective manner and find
enjoyment with her new blended family.
Elizabeth Einstein, a noted author,
speaker, and stepfamily member, has said, "My stepparenting mistakes were not so
much misdeeds as misinformation? It is not uncommon for individuals entering
into a blended family to feel overwhelmed, disoriented, or confused about how to
proceed. Accurate information may be what is needed most. Many second marriages
begin with individuals using the first marriage as a model. Clearly, many of the
principles upon which healthy and happy families are established are true
regardless of family type, but there are also some distinct differences that
must be addressed for a blended family to function in a successful mode.
Libraries have many books on
remarriage. Workshops, classes, and seminars are becoming more available. Many
parents find it very helpful to get involved with other stepfamilies as a way of
supporting and normalizing their experience. Whatever method is chosen, getting
clear and accurate information about blended families is a vital first step to
having a successful experience in the blended family. The following summarizes
the main points:
Become informed about stepfamilies issues.
Read a variety of books and articles on the subject.
Attend workshops, classes, or seminars.
Talk with other stepfamilies.
LOSSES ARE MOURNED
Unlike most first marriages, second marriages are typically formed out of loss.
All family members have experienced significant losses prior to entering into
the new family, and need an opportunity to work through those concerns. This may
be true even several years into the second marriage. There are losses of all
kinds, some of which have gone unrecognizedthe dream of a lifelong loving
relationship, the opportunity to rear children from birth, self-esteem issues,
financial stability, friends, familiar surroundings, daily contact between
parent and child, etc.
No one experiences loss more than the
children. Their lives are changed forever, and yet they feel helpless to have
any impact on the decision of their parents to divorce. Wallerstein and
Blakeslee noted in their longitudinal study that only one in ten children
experienced relief when their parents ended their marriage, and 40 percent of
the children spent the first ten years after their parents' divorce in an
atmosphere of conflict and anger.3 Most wished their parents would have stayed
together; and even if both parents had remarried, some children still had
reconciliation fantasies years later. When divorced individuals remarry,
typically a time of optimism and renewed hope for the adults, children are
forced to acknowledge an end to their dream of their parents' reuniting. The
engagement and wedding can often be a very painful time for children, although
many put on a good show and play the happy part they think their remarrying
parent wants and expects.
In interviews my husband and I
conducted with adolescents from blended families, most children stated they had
never shared their true feelings about the divorce or subsequent second marriage
with either parent. Reasons for the silence included not wanting to hurt the
parent, fear of being misunderstood or blamed, difficulty putting words to
intense feelings, and the belief that the child's wants or needs wouldn't make
any difference anyway. It is common for children to not volunteer much
information about what they are experiencing, and they may need to be invited to
share their concerns. Some find it helpful to have someone other than a parent
available to talk with them.
The loss associated with the death of
a spouse may contribute to some different dynamics than those created by
divorce. Over time a deceased spouse may become idealized, due to the fact that
he or she commits no day-to-day misdeeds to challenge that perception. Sometimes
it feels like a losing battle to the current partner to have to compete with the
perfect memories of the first spouse while coping with the inevitable chaos of
establishing a new family unit.
Both death and divorce represent
tremendous losses to the children and adults involved. With death there is a
clear and definite point in time when the life ended, and most often an external
cause such as disease or accident can be blamed for the loss. Divorce is less
clear, making it more difficult for children to acknowledge the finality of the
act and to bring some closure to this phase of their lives. This is particularly
true if the divorce was preceded by a series of separations and subsequent
reconciliations. Seeing their parents repeatedly decide to give their marriage
another chance may give children the hope that the final separation is just
temporary, that once again the marriage's problems can be repaired.
Divorce is almost always associated
with a sense of guilt for every family member. At some point in time, most
parents wonder if they really tried as hard as they could or worry that they
contributed negatively to the ending of the marriage. Most children also feel a
sense of responsibility for the ending of the marriage, though the adults in
their lives are often unaware of the children's sense of guilt. Children reflect
on their own misbehaviors or recall parental arguments related to them directly.
Just because a legal divorce has been
accomplished does not necessarily signal that an emotional divorce has been
completed. Some people do not know how to mourn the profound loss they have
experienced when a spouse rejects them. For several years after their
separation, Mark continued to feel intensely angry at his former wife, Elise. He
would spend hours planning ways to make her life miserable, such as delaying
child support payments, refusing to return the children on time from visits, or
planting condemning notes in her dates' cars. Sometimes he would arrive late to
work or leave early just so he could spy on her activities. It was not until
Mark learned to let go of his hurt towards Elise that he could move on with his
life, establishing new and healthy relationships of his own and creating a
personal routine centered on his needs and interests. Some people find it
helpful to identify a few very specific goals for themselves and then outline
steps that will likely lead them in that direction. Learning to enjoy the
present and specific goals for themselves and then outline steps that will
likely work towards future plans, rather than reminiscing about the past, seems
to be productive. Consider the following:
Remarriage is often viewed as a second chance by the adults and the loss of a
dream for the children.
Children need to be encouraged to talk about what they are experiencing.
Divorce is often associated with a sense of guilt for everyone.
An emotional divorce may be as critical to achieve as a legal divorce.
EXPECTATIONS ARE REALISTIC
Studies in psychology suggest that when individuals can anticipate what is going
to happen to them, stress levels are lowered. Conversely, if their lives are
full of chaos or things happen differently than is expected, anxiety increases.
It becomes especially important, then, that expectations for the second marriage
are realistic and relationships are not built on beliefs which are unlikely to
be realized.
Paris postulated that women, for
example, may be most vulnerable to the myth that in a successful family everyone
loves everyone else.4 Traditionally, women have been expected to be the glue
that holds the family together; thus, they often run into trouble in second
marriages where members of the family cannot or do not immediately love each
other. Instant love and adjustment are not realistic expectations. Relationships
take time. Integration, or the feeling that the individuals pulled together
actually represent a family unit, depends on the age of the stepchildren and the
length of time they have spent in the stepfamily household. Those who feel
pressured to immediately love another person may miss the opportunity to relax
and to determine if they really do like one another. Research suggests that it
takes one to six years for family members to work through obstacles and to
develop loving feelings for each other. Sometimes even longer is required,
especially if teenagers are brought into the second marriage and thus reach
adulthood and move out of the second marriage household before a strong
relationship has been established.
Several authors have written of
identifiable stages through which most stepfamilies move as they work towards
adjustment and integration. Generally, couples begin with a complex set of
fantasies focused on how they can make this family the special one each had
hoped for the first time. During this phase, couples deny differences, pretend
that the second marriage will allow them to return to where they were before the
former marriage began to deteriorate, and ponder about how to rescue children
from effects of the excesses or inadequacies of the absent biological parent.
This is the time when many children dream that their parents will magically get
back together again. Giving up fantasies is difficult because it means another
loss. Other stages involve experiencing feelings of confusion, jealousy,
resentment, and inadequacy. This may lead to chaos where differences are
expressed more openly.
Ultimately, if families can hang
together through these inevitable ups and downs, solid and reliable stepfamily
relationships develop, and individuals are able to make the commitment to accept
reality and move forward. It can be helpful to realize that these stages are
normal, not necessarily indicative of family dysfunction, and that struggling
together through the many challenges often creates the close bonding that ties
individuals together in significant ways. An important task during these phases
is for family members to understand the notion that stepparent-stepchild
relationships will likely never be exactly the same as biological relationships.
They can be loving, supportive, caring, and healthy, but most often they are
different.
In many respects, blended families
work differently than first-marriage families. It is not necessary for
step-siblings to be best friends or constant companions. It can be healthy for
biological family members to spend some time alone together reminiscing and
strengthening earlier bonds. Sometimes parents will take different roles or have
different rules with various children.
It is helpful to refrain from
comparing current family achievement to a first-marriage model. The success of
the blended family can be judged only in terms of the family's progress toward
the goals they have defined for themselves. Thus, it can be helpful for couples
to spend time discussing future plans that can meet the needs of their new
family unit, avoiding the tendency to try to recreate a first-marriage family.
These meetings can then extend to family councils where every member has the
opportunity to give input. Discussion should center around long-term and
short-term goals for the family, with specific, measurable, and achievable
behaviors geared toward achieving those goals. As the family grows and changes,
goals should be reviewed and revised when necessary. Experience has shown the
following:
Instant love and adjustment are not realistic expectations.
Stepfamilies go through stages as they adjust and integrate.
Struggling together can lead to closer bonding.
Stepfamily relationships can be positive but are usually different than
biological relationships.
Stepfamily success should be measured by progress toward goals family members
have defined for themselves, not by comparison to successes and failures in
family members' previous family units.
THE COUPLE IS UNIFIED
To
the couple of a blended family, it can seem that the moment they say, "I do,"
some of the other significant people in their lives may be saying, "Well, we
don't!" Blended-family parents typically don't have the luxury of months of time
alone to adjust and grow together. Children, and sometimes even extended family
members, may view the new relationship as threatening or ill-conceived, and from
the onset the marriage bond can be stretched to its limits.
Marcia had one six-year-old daughter,
Jenni, when her marriage of eight years ended. At that time she literally
devoted her time and energy to Jenni in an effort to make this major family
transition as easy as possible for her. They shopped and cleaned together, went
on some sort of outing each week, and read stories every night. Marcia allowed
Jenni to sleep in her bed with her in an effort to help her daughter feel more
secure. Jenni was quite happy with the arrangement and would have been very
content for it to continue that way indefinitely. Naturally, when Marcia began
to seriously date Rob, Jenni felt threatened, believing she may be replaced by
him. Jenni liked Rob but feared that her mother would begin to love him more
than her. Soon after Marcia and Rob's marriage, Jenni began creating situations
that forced her mother to choose between them. She became more helpless and
demanding as a way of checking to see if her mother would still come to her aid
when summoned. It seemed as though the rules of this new family unit were
changing, and Jenni was testing the limits. She had felt no control in deciding
about the divorce earlier or about this new marriage, and she wanted to feel
some personal power in what was happening in her life now. And finally, she
didn't want to become attached to Rob if he were going to leave as her father as
done. In all likelihood, Jenni was not consciously aware of how she was feeling
or acting, but was responding at a more instinctual level. While Marcia loved
Rob, she felt responsible to solve the problems with her daughter, once again
devoting most of her time and energy to that purpose. Rob felt hurt, angry, and
left out, wondering if this marriage was a mistake.
The divorce rates for first and
second marriages are about the same, but expressed causes for first and second
divorces differ. In first marriages, children tend to keep the partners together
longer, while in remarriages children are more likely to be a primary
contributing factor to ending relationships. A major difference between first
and second marriages is that in the latter, the parent-child bond predates the
couple's union; when conflicts arise, adults are often naturally pulled toward
family members with whom they have biological ties. Because children are already
present during dating and when the marriage begins, couples do not have the
opportunity to grow and to develop together in the same ways they would if they
were able to experience the joy of pregnancy, to anticipate the birth of their
children, and to participate in the socialization of the infant from birth.
Children in a remarriage can be
disruptive to the couple's relationship. While that is difficult, it is
important to remember that there is always some meaning associated with their
negative behavior. Understanding the children's concerns, fears, and desires is
a vital first step in knowing how to deal with the difficulties. It is important
to let children know that what they are experiencing matters to their parents.
It is also essential to then establish appropriate boundaries within which needs
can be met. A strong dose of expressed love and empathy combined with clear and
explicit limits can be helpful to both children and adults.
Adults in a stepfamily need to plan
for time together as a couple to nourish their own relationship. Locking the
bedroom door to have a private conversation or planning evenings together or
weekends away from the children may not be luxuries but rather necessities in
building the marital strength required in successful stepfamilies. In
well-functioning stepfamilies, remarried parents realize that while their
children continue to need them, they also need the sense of security that comes
from a stable couple and the assurance that the stepfamily unit will continue.
The children also benefit from the example of a happy couple working well
together; this can serve as a positive pattern for the children's future marital
relationships.
Couples should decide together how
they will deal with major issues and then present a unified front to the
children. This is not to say they must always appear to agree, but they should
support each other and demonstrate how to maturely resolve disagreements when
they arise. At first, it is generally better for the biological parent to
discipline. After relationships begin to develop, that role can gradually be
shared by both the biological parent and the stepparent.
Although children are usually the
strongest factor competing for adult attention in a remarriage, many other
things can compete with the couple's relationship. Because of the complexity of
remarriage, time, thoughts, and energy are drawn in many different directions.
Each partner may be adjusting to the new family in different ways. This is
especially true if one is moving into the house already established by the other
or if the new family unit is comprised of both biological children and
stepchildren. Sometimes individuals who have been hurt in earlier relationships
move slowly or too cautiously. There may be extended family members who are
uncertain how to respond to the new family, with all its additional members.
Their reactions may even be negative or hurtful.
Whatever the complications, couples
will do better when they believe in themselves and in the marriage. Individuals
can learn from past mistakes, but there is no need for either partner to make a
complete transformation. Regular conversations in which honest feelings are
shared and real problems are addressed are essential for success. Feelings
follow thoughts, and love can be present as a continual decision. Marriage
relationships should never be taken for granted, and each partner must make
conscious efforts daily to do those things that are productive and helpful for
each other.
In spite of the pain experienced
because of death or divorce, there seems to be a lot of optimism and a general
faith in the institution of marriage, as suggested by the fact that
approximately 70 percent of divorced people will remarry. People report wanting
to be married. Most individuals say they learned from their first marriage
experience, and they better understand what is and is not helpful to a
relationship. Increased and improved communication is reported to be present in
second marriages, and people generally believe they have chosen well a second
partner. Couples involved in second marriages should keep in mind the following:
It can be helpful to everyone to find ways to appropriately respond to the
needs of children.
Stepfamily adults need time alone to nourish their relationship.
Children benefit from experiencing the model of a secure and stable couple
relationship where adults support each other.
Sharing of honest feelings and addressing real problems are important.
SATISFACTORY STEPFAMILY
RELATI0NSHIPS ARE F0RMED
A
stepfamily has reduced chances of being successful unless satisfactory
stepfamily relationships have developed. Just because a couple forms a solid
bond does not automatically mean that other good family relations will develop.
A big surprise and often a disappointment for the adults is the realization that
even after living together for some time, partners often do not love the
stepchildren as much as their own. At the beginning of the marriage there can be
an expectation, sometimes unacknowledged: "If you love me, you love my children.
While this clearly is not always true, the expectation can progress to the
following thought: "If you love my children, then you love me." Almost without
awareness, but nonetheless powerfully, the rule finally shifts to "If you don't
love my children, then you don't love me" This can be a time when the biological
parent is especially sensitive to cues about how the stepparent-stepchild
relationship is progressing, and particular reactions from the stepparent
regarding a stepchild may be perceived as the spouse's either loving or
rejecting the partner who is the child's biological parent.
It is important to be able to be
genuine in a marriage and to feel comfortable expressing honest feelings.
Couples need to be willing to deal with difficult issues and to work together at
problem-solving strategies. It is also important to understand that making an
effort to relate positively to stepchildren can go a long way in enhancing
couple intimacy. For example, when a stepfather goes the extra mile by spending
constructive time alone with a stepchild, giving compliments, and exercising
extra patience, the child's mother may well interpret these actions as
demonstrations of love to her. A mutually satisfying stepfather-stepchild
relationship often seems to be key to the wife's marital happiness, and it may
be at least as important as their relationship as a couple or her relationship
to her own children.
Sometimes children seem to have an
even more difficult time than adults in accepting and loving the parent who has
suddenly come into their lives. For the most part, they do not have a choice in
the remarriage decision, and it is not uncommon for children to have limited
association with the new stepparent before remarriage. It is unrealistic to
expect a child to accept as a parent and especially to experience loving
feelings toward an adult who is relatively unknown. Relationships take time to
develop, regardless of the marital or legal status of family members. In
addition, children already have a father and a mother; this is true even if one
of those parents has died or has never been known to the child. When they have
continued contact with their biological parents, children usually do not want or
need stepparents for general psychological survival. Stepparents who, at least
initially, define their role with their stepchildren as that of friend are
usually most satisfied. Children seem less threatened by a friendship
relationship and are often relieved to not feel pressured to choose between two
fathers or two mothers. They have the room to begin to see the stepparent as
another caring adult who can add to their lives, rather than feeling forced to
let go of someone important to them.
Children deserve to have the
opportunity to have a relationship with both parents, regardless of the parents'
differing views. Under most circumstances they love both parents, in spite of
the adults' individual weaknesses, and they see a part of themselves in their
mother and father. Rarely is it in their best interest to deny visitation or to
try to turn them against the other parent. When children are refused the chance
to be with a parent, they may begin to idealize him or her, conveniently
forgetting all past mistakes or omissions. Sometimes as they get older, children
resent the custodial parent, who they believe robbed them of an important
relationship during critical developmental years-a relationship they feel cannot
be recreated. Interestingly, children who are allowed and encouraged to interact
with biological parents tend to feel permission to develop good relationships
with stepparents. When a parent has been particularly abusive or neglectful,
they may choose not to have frequent contact. But then, because it is their
choice, the custodial parent is not viewed as punishing or manipulative.
Step-relationships do not have to be
the same as biological relationships to be good and satisfying. Letting go of
the need to have the blended family look and feel like a first-marriage family
is important to helping it move ahead in a healthy, satisfying way.
Jealousy is a common issue in
stepfamilies, and, surprisingly to most involved, no one seems to be exempt from
this particular emotion. Children often are jealous as they see their parent
spending time with a relative stranger and openly expressing feelings of great
caring and emotion. During the first year of our marriage, we asked each of our
children to fill out a simple questionnaire about their stepfamily experience.
While we were not successful in having them spend much time talking to us about
what this was like for them, they were willing to write. I could not have been
more surprised to learn that a major concern for one of Brent's daughters was
that he might love me more than her. She did not want to be replaced or, worse
yet, forgotten.
Jealousy between step-siblings occurs
as one child believes the other receives preferential treatment, has more
things, is disciplined less, etc. Fair does not always mean equal, and this can
be a difficult concept for both parents and children to understand and
appreciate. Another of our daughters, only a few months ago, said, "In some ways
it's harder for me now because I feel more compared than I did when I was
younger. The realities of the children's seven more years of school, their
choice of friends and hobbies, and their extracurricular activities have
inevitably taken the children on somewhat different paths from each other. While
we try very hard to appreciate each of our children for their individual talents
and qualities, differences are apparent.
Jealousy of one's spouse's children
seems to be one of the most confusing and unexpected emotions related to
remarriage, and it is often difficult for adults to make sense of it at an
intellectual level. This can be particularly true if both spouses have children
of comparable ages behaving in not-so-comparable ways. Steven, for example, has
two daughters who live with his former wife. He has visitation on Wednesday
evenings and every other weekend and is never happier than when he is with them.
Both daughters are talented, socially adept, but not particularly interested in
scholarly pursuits. Steven's current wife, Wendy, also has two daughters, and
they excel in school. Each time they receive an honor or bring home a glowing
report card, Steven experiences conflicting feelings of pride mixed with
disappointment toward his own children. This is followed by guilt for having
such immature and unsupportive thoughts. It is naturally difficult to feel the
same degree of pleasure in the accomplishments of individuals for whom there is
no natural tie, especially when those successes are reminders of less successful
experiences of others who hold an important role.
Loyalty conflicts are often related
to the jealousies experienced and can be extremely common. Some children have
indicated that they can not allow themselves to like the new stepparent because
it somehow represents a betrayal of the absent biological parent. The reverse
can also be true for the stepparents. Feeling loving, proud, or concerned for a
step-relative can be self-interpreted as a lack of loyalty to the corresponding
biological family member. Simply acknowledging true feelings and understanding
why they may appear from time to time can be helpful in normalizing the
stepfamily experience. This may lead to open discussion, which tends to
ultimately have beneficial impact.
The transitions required during
visitation are often difficult for children to negotiate, even under the best of
circumstances. They become more difficult if children believe they are expected
to spy or if they are told negative things about the absent parent, again
creating great loyalty concerns. It is most helpful to focus with them on the
positive aspects of their visits, avoid interrogating or prying about the other
household, and allow children some adjustment time when they return from visits
with the other biological parent. If their blended family's home is consistently
a safe place where they are not forced into choosing sides or engaging in
behavior that feels hurtful, they will be less likely to resist going to visit
and returning.
Points to remember:
Satisfactory step-relationships can develop with time and effort.
Good step-relationships tend to support good couple relationships.
Continued contact with both biological parents is important to the children.
Step-relationships do not have to be the same as biological relationship to be
good and satisfying.
Feelings of jealousy and conflicts of loyalty are normal aspects of stepfamily
adjustment.
CONSTRUCTIVE RITUALS ARE DEVELOPED
Celebrations and traditions that are repeated year after year create family
continuity, good relationships, happy memories, and feelings of belonging. These
can be important details that pull family members together. In first marriages
these traditions seem to evolve and develop over time. Sometimes what feels very
important to children may register as rather insignificant to adults-and vice
versa. Regardless of whether these rituals are formalized or result quite by
chance, healthy and cohesive families can define important rituals in their
lives.
The feeling of disconnectedness that
sometimes prevails in new remarriages often is related to the lack of family his
story as the stepfamily begins. Each family member may have ways of doing things
that can seem "right" or "best" and they can resent or resist another's way of
doing the same thing. Sometimes there can be a sense of loss when old
habits-maybe as simple as a bedtime routine-suddenly disappear. Changes in more
major events can be even more distressing. This can be a time for summoning
imagination and being willing to experiment with new ideas.
Brett and Karen finally decided to
settle a family dispute by having two Thanksgiving dinners, one with turkey and
dressing on Thursday afternoon and the other with roasted duck on Thanksgiving
Eve with Karen's family. The couple's inventiveness was challenged again only a
month later at Christmastime when the children finally agreed to the suggestion
that opposite sides of the tree could be decorated quite differently-one with
strings of popcorn and cranberries and he other with candles and tiny wooden
German ornaments. Each family set wanted to retain its former holiday
traditions, and fortunately this couple was able to creatively incorporate key
elements of both into their new stepfamily traditions. This problem-solving
strategy was applied to how birthdays were celebrated, how family vacations were
organized, etc., and to even more routine events such as dinnertime,
housecleaning, and homework rules.
Brett and Karen found a way that
worked for them, but it may not fit with every family style. The specifics of
which situations to plan and of how these situations are handled probably are
not as significant as recognizing the importance that is attached to the rituals
and dealing with them in ways that feel comfortable for the individuals
involved. Many step-families have found that creating new family traditions,
with everyone included from the start, can be a very satisfying way of dealing
with this issue. Rituals may be seemingly insignificant things such as a subtle
gesture to send a specific meaning or clearly defined routines such as
celebrating special events.
There can be a clear advantage to
creating new traditions for days or events in such a way that the blended
family's special occasions will likely not be in conflict with those planned by
a former spouse. For example, having a grand yearly celebration for the day this
group of people became a new family unit can promote closeness and family
identity. Others have chosen to observe Labor Day or Groundhog Day or to create
their own holiday if special days are established and more minor rituals
observed as well, unique to the new family unit alone, the more traditional
holidays sometimes are easier to negotiate. Successful remarried families also
work out innovative ways of dealing with transitions for holidays and the manner
in which children move back and forth between two households for visitation.
Some LDS families have reported that
Sunday church attendance and Monday-night family home evenings are natural ways
of pulling children together in a format with which they are already
comfortable. Reading scriptures together, praying before each meal, and
preparing for a sibling's mission are all familiar things that can contribute to
a feeling of belonging together and doing what is right.
While it is important to find times
to work and play together as an entire group, it is also essential to remember
that each family member needs his or her own time and space. Planning occasions
when either one or both parents can have a "date" with one child can make that
particular child feel acknowledged and special and at the same time allow the
others to anticipate their own turn. Open discussions, alone or in a group,
allow children to express their thoughts and feel as though their unique
perspectives contribute to the whole. When family members feel secure in their
value to the family, they may be more willing to share and cooperate. Consider
the following:
Family traditions, based on interests of all family members, are necessary to
ensure good relationships and feelings of belonging.
Creating new rituals can be valuable to the stepfamily and help with
transitions for holidays or visitation.
Balancing family activities with time for individual interests is important.
THE LDS BLENDED FAMILY
Without question, LDS remarried families are likely to have some questions that
may not even be considered by families of other faiths. One of the most common
concerns relates to the concept of the eternal nature of the family. While
divorces are not forbidden, they certainly are not encouraged. Great emphasis is
given to better understanding problems, resolving conflicts, and enhancing
personal communication and negotiation skills within the existing family unit.
When a divorce does take place, it may be perceived as a clear indication that
the couple is off course or has deviated from the sacred plan. Families are
supposed to be forever, and there is not a comfortable way of fitting a "broken"
family into the bigger scheme of things. Not uncommonly, LDS single adults talk
of not feeling a part of a culture that so clearly stresses the importance of
being a member of a larger family. Those negative feelings can be even more
intense when divorce is the reason for being single.
Often when an individual remarries,
there is a great sense of relief felt by ward and family members. Marriage is
considered a most sacred ordinance, and it is highly valued because it can be
that special kind of relationship in which love, support, and trust abound.
Remarriage can lend the appearance that the individuals are back on course,
living the eternal plan, even though their righteousness or diligence in
following the commandments may not have changed from how it was when they were
single. Sadly, it can sometimes feel to the remarried couple that the appearance
of being one solid unit is what is most important and that the complexities of
stepfamily relationships, such as family members living in other households,
should not be openly discussed. They may try to present themselves in ways more
typical of a first-marriage family, avoiding the very things which could lead to
a closer and more cohesive family bonding. Thus, remarried families often fail
to receive the understanding and support which could be helpful to them; in
addition, they do not feel they have permission to do things differently than
what they typically consider to be the norm.
In addition to feeling the need to be
and look like a first-marriage family, less obvious but more personal or
far-reaching issues may be of concern. When a couple is legally divorced, they
may also receive a cancellation of the religious sealing-essentially, a temple
divorce. Although a man and a woman may remarry and may be sealed to new
spouses, there is no provision for sealing children to more than one set of
parents. Their sealing to the original set of parents remains intact, regardless
of marital status of the two biological parents of the children. It is sometimes
helpful to explain that the blessings and promises the children received as part
of the sealing ordinance belongs individually regardless of what ever happens to
other family members. Nevertheless, it can be difficult to explain to the
children, and even to parents themselves, how their family will be configured in
the eternities.
In this chapter, I have tried to
offer some practical suggestions for being happy and feeling successful in a
stepfamily. It is important to remember that suggestions will be most helpful
when we approach our challenges from a spiritual perspective. Heavenly Father is
loving and benevolent, and he wants us to be happy. We are not expected to be
perfect, but,- rather, our experience on earth is given to help us learn and
grow from our mistakes. The family unit is without question the basis for all
that is important in the building of the kingdom. We should focus all our
efforts toward preserving and strengthening the family unit, whether it is a
first-marriage family or a blended family. When we are righteous and humbly seek
his guidance, Heavenly Father will be there to help us succeed, no matter what
our circumstances may be.
Sometimes, in our weakness, we make
mistakes that can have dramatic ramifications for ourselves and for others who
are very important to us. When that happens, we have been given the gift of
repentance. We may not be able to fix what has been broken, but we should move
ahead in the best ways we can, always focusing on self-improvement and enhancing
our relationships. At other times, events occur which are out of our control,
but which also have impact on us in deeply significant ways. Because we do not
have a complete vision of the greater plan of our Father in Heaven, we may
sometimes see things as unfair and even hopeless. But we must remember that we
have repeatedly been promised, both in scripture and by modern-day prophets and
apostles, that the Lord will assist us in all our righteous endeavors.
Heavenly Father is there to help us
be at peace, accomplish the necessary tasks of this life, and return to his
presence. The structure and programs of the Church are designed to help all
types of family units do just that, and adherence to gospel principles is good
for everyone in every circumstance.
Stepfamily living certainly brings
with it added complexities. Sometimes that is because of the internal nature of
the many interrelated family connections. Sometimes it is because those around
us do not fully understand what is happening and may not be as supportive or
helpful as they could be.
Regardless of the reasons for
challenges or the difficulty of dealing with many complications, a fulfilling,
positive, and happy experience is truly possible in a second marriage. There are
hundreds of references in the scripture dealing with children and families and
in not one case is a blended family excluded from those blessings and promises.
Struggling, learning, and growing in the most holy of associations -the family -
can prepare us to rise to our eternal destiny. "All these things shall
give thee experience, and shall be for thy good" (D&C 122:7).
Here are some points to remember:
· Adherence to gospel principles is good for all types of families.
· Heavenly Father loves and helps all families.
· Blended families can be "forever" families.
CONCLUDING COMMENT
One of my most treasured experiences occurred this past Mother's Day. The
Saturday before Mother's Day, I spent the afternoon with my own mother as we
placed flowers on the graves of my grandmother, great-grandmother, great-great
grandmother, and several other relatives I know only from the stories my mother
has told. I had a strong sense of the continuity of life and felt love for these
important women in my history, even though it was a very different love than
that which I feel for my own mother. I spent the next day with my family,
attending church, eating a dinner prepared by my son and his new bride, and
celebrating with all my stepchildren, their spouses, and our three grandchildren
during the evening. I felt this ending to a pleasant day was particularly
significant: Brent's children chose to come visit me even though he was out of
town on business. Once again I felt an abundance of love and appreciation for
all these family members, realizing anew the importance of different kinds of
relationships.
It is difficult for me to explain how
much I love my own three children. They are always in my thoughts, and I love to
spend time with them whenever possible. It is equally difficult, but different,
to try to express the love I have for my step-daughters and the relationships we
have developed over the past seven years. We continue to grow together, and I
value their friendship, example, and consideration of me. Our relationship is
not always perfect, but it is satisfying and fills an important place in my
heart.
NOTES
1. Emily B. Visher and John S. Visher, "Dynamics of Successful Stepfamilies,"
Journal of Divorce and Remarriage 14 (July 1990): 3-12.
2. Elizabeth Einstein, The Stepfamily: Living, Loving and Learning (Ithaca, New
York: Elizabeth A. Einstein, 1994), 124.
3. Judith S. Wallerstein and Sandra Blakeslee, Second Chances (New York: Ticknor
and Fields, 1990), 13.
4. E. Paris, Stepfamilies: Making Them Work (New York: Avon Books, 1985).
|
|